

Clinical Kiwis tame Lions
The first test. All of that build up. All of the excitement. The thrills of the opening fifty minutes or so. The outcome? A deflating and frustrating 30-15 loss for the Lions.
New Zealand were at their clinical and skilful best. Surprisingly, they didn’t create as many chances as the visitors, but taught a valuable lesson in how to finish off opportunities that come your way. They played with fire and outmuscled the tourists – nullifying the supposed strengths of the Lions. For Warren Gatland’s side and his planned box of tricks for the test series, the main surprises were an attacking flair not seen until now, a struggle in the set piece and the breakdown, and a series of substitutions that seemed premeditated and took the pace out of the game.
Starting in blistering fashion, the Lions almost went over through Elliot Daly within minutes. Unfortunately, it wasn’t finished off – a fixture of this tour, and one which is yet to rectify itself. Both sides were going at it hammer and tong. Typically, it was the hosts who got the breakthrough with a quick-thinking Codie Taylor try, Beauden Barrett knocking over the conversion and a penalty. Owen Farrell got his side on the board, but Barrett cancelled that three-pointer out immediately. The Lions were being outmuscled and out-thought, but were holding firm in defence and the excellent Jonathan Davies and Liam Williams were looking threatening. With the half coming to an end, Williams kick-started a move in his own 22 that resulted in one of the greatest Lions tries, finished by Sean O’Brien. The score was 13-8 at the interval and here was hope. Even more so when they went incredibly close early in the second half, but again threw the opportunity away. As they do, New Zealand made them pay, extending the lead to 30-8 without batting an eyelid. Rieko Ioane grabbed a ruthless brace and Barrett slotted another seven points from the boot. The Lions bench was emptied, and whilst individually they did OK, they struggled to get into the pace of the game and gel. Rhys Webb sniped for a late consolation; something to cling onto next week, but meaningless as the Kiwis cruised to victory.
As Warren Gatland pointed out: everything is fixable. More to the point is whether it can be fixed within a week. Defensive lapses and lack of aggression could be rectified with the inclusion of Courtney Lawes, whilst somebody with a finishers instinct could put these opportunities away. The All Blacks will be creating far more than they did at the weekend though, which means that Lions will need to sort all of this out and some, otherwise the series will have slipped away without them noticing.
Scotland suffer comedown, Ireland and Wales clean sweeps
The impressive start to Gregor Townsend’s reign as Scotland coach was tempered with defeat to Fiji. Coming off the back of a famous victory in Australia, the tourists were expected to make it three from three, but they were unable to live with an inspired Fiji. The Scots outscored their hosts three tries to two, but giving away far too many kickable penalties cost them dear, alongside magnificent scores from Peceli Yato and Henry Seniloli.
Japan put in an improved performance against Ireland, but ultimately remain way behind their World Cup group counterparts after a 35-13 loss. Wales had to bounce back through two Steff Evans tries to see off Samoa 19-17. South Africa sealed a series whitewash against France with a 35-12 victory, whilst Australia survived a scare against Italy, who perhaps should have won, instead losing 40-27 after two late tries. Argentina were 45-29 victors against Georgia.
Hero of the week
For Fiji to beat a tier 1 nation is a feat in itself. To beat a Scottish side riding high after beating Australia on tour the week before is most certainly one of their biggest results outside of a World Cup.
Villain of the week
I hate to sound like I’m complaining about the result; I am not, because New Zealand definitely deserved to win. Also, if there was an obvious contender, I wouldn’t be choosing this. However, I really don’t know how New Zealand get away with so many forward passes, amongst other infringements. Most of the time, decisions are right (which I thought all of the decision that went against the Lions were), and when they’re wrong, it tends to level out over a game. With the All Blacks, I’m not convinced that that is the case.
Try of the week
It may have been the only time that the Lions managed to finish an opportunity whilst the game was still alive, but my what a try! One of the greats. Initiated by Liam Williams from his own 22, scything through and involving some neat interchange between Elliot Daly and Jonathan Davies, before Sean O’Brien crashed over to ensure the Lions were still in it at the break.
Discussion points
- What do the Lions need to do differently next week?
- What do they need to keep the same?
- Which players need to be replaced? By whom?
- Who stood out for your team on their summer tour?
By Joe Large
Strangely lost our way on 35mins after a period of play where brodie retallick could have been yellow carded 3 times…. We never recovered, it got worse after pom went off, sexton was very off pace, kruis looked very tired on 55mins… Webb should have come on sooner… Next weekend start itoje drop awj (just not dynamic enough), put lawes on bench, drop sexton and Halfpenny and bring in jj and Russell… Biggest test next Saturday!
0
All of us who watch super rugby know that kicking the ball away is futile unless into open space or even to touch.We must also take chances when they are created .We had three only last week end and missed the boat.Quick ball from rucks and mauls is also a must and we can win thia week end.Go Lions.
0
Absolutely no way you win a test match if you lose the breakdown that comprehensively. I’d bring in Itoje for Jones and Warburton for SOB to address it but I wouldn’t make any other changes.
Jones was so poor, as expected, so I’m hoping to see him out of the 23 this weekend. I actually thought SOB was brilliant, but Warburton is better at the breakdown and I wouldn’t sacrifice the line out work for POM for SOB carrying.
I’ve found the criticism of Kruis quite off. The one area of the game I thought we dominated was the line out, which is what he’s there for! I’d agree that he wasn’t his normal all action self in the loose but he shouldn’t be dropped for that.
The back line shouldn’t change, as it was another area I thought we performed really well. I would go with a 6-2 split this weekend though. I We have enough options to be able to have just Webb and Sexton on the bench and cover most things.
Mako, George, Furlong, Itoje, Kruis, O’Mahony, Warburton, Faletau, Murray, Farrell, Daly, Te’o, Davies, Watson, Williams
Owens, McGrath, Sinkler, Lawes, SOB, Stander, Webb, Sexton
Also, goes anyone else think that there is a certain English captain that would have thrived on Saturday? Lions getting beaten upfront, particularly in the breakdown on tight carries… Hartley would have none of that!
0
Well said Jacob. We also need to improve fringe defence as there were too many instances of AB’s coming through the middle of rucks or round the fringes.
0
Agree with a lot of this Jacob but Warburton did nothing when he came on and still looks short of form.. I would have Stander or Haskell in preference, both of whom bring a bit of grunt if nothing else. Totally disagree about “a certain English captain”. He would have been even further off the pace here than he was in most of the six nations. Doesn´t carry effectively and this was just the sort of game that he would probably imploded with frustration and left us a man short. (Not that one would notice with Hartley most of the time).
0
I do agree that Warburton wasn’t completely outstanding when he came on, but his timing at the breakdown is as good as anyone in world rugby and I feel like the gamble is worth it – we simply can’t lose at the breakdown again and at full fitness he is the best in that area that we have.
Hartley – well there are always people that strongly hate him but I’m nowhere near that camp. He has deficiencies but the guy fronts up and leads by example. His work at the breakdown is underrated and he is a really good fringe defender, never taking a backwards step.
The “frustration” and “imploding” stuff, I just think it’s media hype. The guy has never been sent off in an England shirt so I don’t see why it’d be different for the Lions. Anyway, not that relevant as I can’t see him ending up on this tour!
0
Completely agree that the Lions need to slow down the NZ ball. NZ didn’t seem to make many line breaks, but they consistently made yards with every carry, due to the fact that the ball was recycled so quickly.
Itoje to come in for AWJ, he’s usually very good at getting his legs through rucks and disrupting. Would probably swap in Warburton to do the same, with SOB dropping to the bench.
I’d then go for Lawes on the bench, and take out halfpenny for probably JJ or Nowell, but if North has a stormer against the Hurricanes I’d consider bringing him in.
Not expecting the Lions to level the series at the weekend, but I’d really like for them to throw a few curve-balls the way of NZ.
0
I’d have North in after his performance against the Hurricanes with Watson who needs to add half a stone in bulk at this rarefied level against the Abs on the bench.
Itoje in for a repeat of Krutoje.
Lawes on the bench and Warbs in.
0