
Anthony Foley
The opening weekend of European Rugby was overshadowed by the death of Anthony ‘Axel’ Foley, the Munster coach and general Irish Rugby legend. With 62 Ireland caps and 201 appearances for Munster, the only top tier side he played for, Foley has been described as a great Rugby man, a Number 8 that would run over you during the game and then find you for a beer afterwards.
Our thoughts are with his young family, his friends and all those that were close to him.
European Rugby gets going with a bang on the pitch
If ever a competition needed an exhilarating opening weekend of action, this was it. The European Champions Cup has been on the receiving end of some abuse since it’s re-imagination and rebranding from the Heineken Cup. Fans have been disillusioned as TV money has talked and seemingly given the rich French and English clubs a distinct advantage. In the two seasons it has been in place, only one team from outside these countries has made it out of the group stages.
So, when Leicester Tigers rocked up at a raucous Scotstoun to face Glasgow Warriors, all eyes were on the game to see what would come of it. If Leicester ground out a victory in such a tight group, it would leave the Scots facing an uphill struggle to stay in the competition. Thankfully, for every neutral, Glasgow didn’t just win; they dominated and put their name down as serious contenders. Gregor Townsend had said that this competition was a priority for his group of talented players, and the fire that they showed completely backed this up.
The opening was feisty and ferocious when every player on the pitch reacted to the Tigers debutant Matt Toomua’s tip-tackle on Finn Russell, where he was lucky to escape with only a yellow card. The tone was set. Even when Leicester took the lead through an Adam Thompstone try, and Ryan Wilson had received a yellow of his own, the home team were intense and uncompromising in everything they did.
In a blistering spell, they scored three tries by exploiting Leicester’s porous defence, particularly having a lot of ‘luck’ around the fringes of the ruck. The way they kept the ball moving and the defence retreating was a joy to behold. They went in 22-13 up and came back out in much the same vein. The defence left Tigers wondering what to do with the ball, and when they had the opportunity, they were lethal. Nobody epitomised this more than Man-Of-The-Match Leonardo Sarto, who finished off a fine game with an intercept try for his second score, leaving Leicester staring at an embarrassing 42-13 defeat.
It was arguably the performance of the weekend. They will need to nick an away win somewhere (probably at Welford Road), but should be confident of their best run in the tournament. Let’s leave any Tigers talk…
Saracens show steel and Northampton nab win
The champions served up a reminder of the favourites tag they possess, beating three time champions Toulon in the south coast of France. It was the first time the French side had been defeated at home in this competition and the nature of the loss was even harder to take. The first half from Sarries was impeccable. They scored three tries and left the crowd livid as they went in 25-6 up. A couple of yellow cards nearly derailed the effort, as Levan Chilachava and Bryan Habana got tries to get back within touching distance, but the returning Owen Farrell nailed a late penalty to deny the hosts even a losing bonus point, leaving the score 31-23.
Losing at home is never a good sign in Europe, and they may travel to Allianz Park later in the season with the unenviable task of having to win to qualify. Saracens are already up and running for a title defence they will be more than confident about.
Stephen Myler slotted a penalty with the last kick of the game as Northampton beat Montpellier 16-14. The hosts had had a disappointing start to the premiership season and needed this to springboard themselves properly into a different competition. Saints made full use of a lethargic beginning by the French, with Callum Clark barging over. Francois Steyn replied with one of his own before the break, but Saints went in ahead. Last season’s second tier winners got a couple of penalties to take the lead, before Myler showed a nerveless edge to get Saints four vital points.
Mixed bag for Irish teams
Unfortunately, the overriding feeling in Ireland this weekend will be one of grief, no matter who you cheer for. I will refrain from talking about it too much, as there will be many people that knew Foley who can write real tributes, but feel free to leave your memories of the Munster legend in the comments.
Connacht picked up their biggest European win, seeing off Toulouse 23-21 in Galway. The Irish province has already started to really turn around what was a dreadful start to the season. They left themselves with a mini mountain to climb, but kept the former European heavyweights scoreless in the second half, whilst scoring tries through Tiernan O’Halloran and Bundee Aki. With Zebre in the group, both these sides will be confident of qualifying.
Despite their excellent start in the Pro12, Ulster were left reeling in Bordeaux. They lead for the majority of the game, but conceded three tries in the final ten minutes to go down 28-13. How they lost control will be the urgent question that needs answering ahead of Exeter’s visit next week.
A bonus point win over Castres in Dublin has Leinster in a very nice position after the first round of games. A poor season last year looks like it may have kicked the three time winners up the bottom. They never let Castres have a sniff, scoring five tries and converting four of them in a 33-15 win
Clermont clinical, Cipriani stars and Scarlets see off Sale
Exeter Chiefs were thoroughly disappointing in their loss to Clermont. The Frenchmen were under the kosh at the start, but then cut loose to win 35-8. The defence from the Devonians was akin to Tigers in parts; soft and not making their opponents work for tries, alongside mistakes. They showed moments going forward, but errors undid all the good work. As for Clermont, they look the French team most likely to do it this year. Every opportunity, they seemed to score and were meaty and physical. With an away victory already, they should make it through this tight group.
Danny Cipriani controlled the game expertly from fly half, guiding his team to a twelve try, 82-14 romp over Zebre. It won’t be a competition the Italians will target, obviously, but the scoreline will endlessly please Wasps. They should comfortably make it out of the pool, and will have eyes on going even further than last year.
The only Welsh team in the competition, Scarlets, won 28-11 over a Sale team who still struggle on the road. The game was as comfortable as could be, but they will perhaps be a little disappointed not to bag a bonus point in a competition that places such high importance on them.
What to say about the Challenge Cup?
This tournament needs reinventing already, however it did produce some interesting results.
Worcester travelled to Russia to face Enisei-STM and lost 19-12. It’s not the first big result that the Russians have got at home in this competition, but if they can back this up away, it would be great to see them in the knockouts.
Harlequins and Gloucester proved themselves as the team’s from England most likely to take the competition as a realistic chance of silverware. The Londoners smashed Stade Francais 43-21 and the cherry and whites beat Bayonne 47-27 in France.
In a result of rarity for a French team, Stade Rochelais went away to Treviso and looked like they wanted to be there. They won 41-10 and may have eyes on a double. Lyon also went away, to fellow Frenchmen Grenoble, and the 39-13 scoreline in their favour may tell a story about their ideas in the competition.
Edinburgh also won big. The Timisoara Saracens from Romania were on the end of a 59-17 hiding. Ospreys smashed Newcastle 45-0 and Dragons beat Brive 37-16, whilst Cardiff made the short trip to Bristol and won 33-20. Bath also started with a victory, 25-22 in Pau.
Try of the weekend
I wanted Glasgow to go over after Sarto’s break (and I am a Tigers fan). It would have made this decision easy. There were a number of other good ones, but Nick Abendanon’s for Clermont after some neat offloading was pretty nice. We’ll try to find the video.
Hero of the weekend
Two tries and a break that would have set up a certain try of the weekend, if they had finished it. Leonardo Sarto was literally everywhere in defence and attack. An absolutely inspired performance. If only his countrymen could put a performance together in this competition for their teams.
Villain of the weekend
It could have gone to Matt Toomua, but he scraped away with only a yellow and, whilst deserving of a red, there was nothing malicious in it. Instead, I will give it to the numpty that took away the carrot of Champions Cup qualification for the winner of the Challenge Cup. The competition literally means nothing again. Only during the latter stages will teams take it seriously, and even then it will be dependent on how they are doing domestically.
By Joe Large
Photo by: Patrick Khachfe / Onside Images
From a personal perspective, what a great opening weekend for Sarries. I thought they could beat Toulon away, but I didn’t really expect us to, and certainly not in the way that we did.
The mixture of forwards and backs play was impeccable and at times you would be fooled to think some of the forwards were playing as centres. The passes from Kruis to Itoje and on to Wyles were absolute class and Jamie George was just everywhere when an attack was on.
Cipriani had a great game to guide Wasps to a thumping victory over Zebre but, given the opposition I suspect he may have been outshone by the returning Owen Farrell.
Very impressed with Jamie George. Even if Hartley is fit I would consider starting George with the form he is in.
George just seemed to be everywhere. Kruis was equally as impressive as well. Throwing dummies and running through the defence. His pass to Itoje for Wyles’s try was something to behold.
Found this highlight video of the Chiefs v Clermont game. Clermont look very dangerous!! http://www.epcrugby.com/matchdaytv
They do look rather good. I expected better from Exeter though
Not sure how Fofana’s first try wasn’t called back for the almost American Football style obstruction in the build up!
I moaned about the commentators not explaining that as it was a good decision, just not an obvious one. In my opinion, hopefully correctly, the “obstructing” player was behind the ball (just) so can’t cause offside / obstruction. If that’s not the case, then I’m as puzzled as you are…
Just watched it again on the highlight link above. If he is behind the ball carrier then it is a matter of centimetres. But to refresh my memory, I looked up the rules and 10.1.c surely applies irrespective of where the ‘obstructing’ player is;
http://laws.worldrugby.org/?law=10&language=EN
” Blocking the tackler. A player must not intentionally move or stand in a position that prevents an opponent from tackling a ball carrier. ”
There is no doubt in my mind that the Exeter player was blocked from making the tackle
I don’t disagree in that case so I’ll go back to being annoyed it wasn’t explained by the pundits. I’m still giving the ref the benefit of the doubt as he used the TMO well generally I thought so must have been happy. The movement / “block” was very obvious, including arms up to make sure it was seen. Feel like we’re missing something…
In any event, impressive stuff from Claremont and disappointing from Exeter. I was hoping for another English win there despite the form book.
I can’t help but feel the structure needs looking at again. It seems crazy to me that the Challenge Cup winners don’t get a place in the Champions Cup – it devalues the competition.
I also think that forcing an Italian team into the Champions Cup is just pointless. Surely they’d be better served by playing a competitive European fixture in the Challenge Cup? Is this format really adding an value to the players or fans in Italy?
A situation where the top 6 from the Prem and Top 14 qualified, the top 7 from the Pro12 (actual top 7) and then the Challenge Cup winner, would be better for everyone involved?
Cips was obviously brilliant, but against really poor opposition. Really glad to see Farrell back, and even more pleased to hear he played really well.
Only an Irish team could score the try that Connacht scored at the weekend and get no mention. Im used to it by now anyway.
It’s just to check if you’re still reading :)
I happened to see most of the Connacht game, and was so impressed with their attacking play, and that try you mentioned was indeed awesome.
Here it is for those that haven’t seen it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p3ekWSO7TGg
I apologise about my choice of try of the week. That one definitely deserved it!
What makes it even more impressive is it came from a defensive line out five metres (or something like that) out from there own try line.
If I remember correctly it was a defensive lineout just outside their own 22 that they turned over. And watching that game, if I was from out Wesht, I’d be very hopeful of getting something in France. Connacht didn’t play as well as they could, and still had all of the imagination and creativity. Toulouse never even looked like they’d try anything other than run into people, and they just couldn’t keep up with the pace. It seemed like every penalty had at least one of them down, trying to catch their breath.
Sadly thats how French rugby has gone, Clermont aside has any French side this weekend played any different? Also Connacht have a horrendous injury list, high teens to 20 players out including there top try scorer from last season. Plus with the way Toulouse play I wouldn’t even be surprised if Zebre give them a game in Parma, yes they where awful against Wasps but they know themselves they won’t be able to live with the way Connacht and Wasps play so they might keep there powder dry for Toulouse. If Toulouse are out come round 6 its very hard to see past Connacht as they will have players back and will be full of confidence.
As for the Irish teams this weekend, ofcourse being a Munster fan there is a feeling of despair in the air. Don’t think ive been this sad about the death of a sport idol in my life. RIP.
Leinster : The one thing Leinster are lacking I feel is a speedy winger and the frustrating thing is they have one at there disposal with Adam Byrne yet for some reason are reluctant to play him. Leinster have a pack that can compete with the best packs of Europe, serious depth, strong coaching with the influence of Graham Henry ( you can see his influence in how Leinster play, the loss to Connacht in last years final I think thought Leinster that 1D rugby is only going to get you so far) and ofcourse Stuart Lancaster. Castres though are probably the weakest side from the Top 14 in the Champions cup so next weeks match with Montpellier will be a huge indicator of where Leinster are, I think even a LBP wouldn’t be the worst result in the world.
Ulster : Worst performance Ive seen from Ulster in a long time, I saw a crazy stat that from the 40th minute to the 73rd minute Ulster spent a total of 1 second in the Bordeaux 22, totally unacceptable. Ulster will need to win next week with probably a Bonus point for moral aswell as the competition. I do feel if Ulster improve they can still be dark horses to win it at the moment but if they get through the group they will have Marcell Coetzee which will be the player who will give Ulster the umph to push them into the contenders bracket.
Connacht : With that Result Connacht are a serious chance of advancing to the knockout phase, with Zebre coming up and with Toulouse going to Coventry it could be Connacht 9 Toulouse 1 going into round 3, I cant see Connacht getting more than a point out of the 2 matches with Wasps so they may have to beat Toulouse away to seal qualification so the hope for Connacht is Toulouse have nothing to play for going into round 6. Outside of the scrum Toulouse have got nothing to hurt Connacht.
Leinster: Still well below the level they were at 2-3 years ago but showing some signs of promise. However they are in a group of under performing teams including my team Northampton. If they can steal a win at the gardens in December then they have a great chance of qualifying
Ulster: French teams are always tough away but with such a competitive group them bonus points are going to be crucial and failure to take anything away will probably come back to haunt them
Connacht: That’s more like it and the try you mentioned was pure class. with 10 points from Zebre they are almost guaranteed a 2nd place finish at the minimum.
Matt O’Connor who took over from Schmidt did serious damage to Leinster with the awful brand of rugby he brought, Cullen along with his coaching staff have been doing an excellent job trying to bring Leinster back to the good old days, although it will take something special to bring them back to the Schmidt days.
What is pleasing for Leinster is that the old man of their 10-12-13 channel is Henshaw, at a geriatric 23. If they can keep that together, that’s a big positive for both them and Ireland.
Totally agree with you on this one. The ball carrier does nothing wrong but his team mate moves alongside him and blocks the Exeter player from making a tackle.
I can’t actually see a French team winning it this year, other than maybe Clermont (maybe Racing as I haven’t seen them play). They’re all too big, and slow, and IMO they lack the fitness and creativity to keep up with the better English/Pro 12 teams. And I feel that once a lot of them hit the first major obstacle, they’ll focus on their league instead. Yeah, Connacht have had so many injuries that when O’Hallaran went over his knee my heart was in my mouth. Especially because I’d like to see him start there vs Canada, or at least come on. Ringrose too. And I agree, if I was Zebre and targeting a game, it would be in Italy against Toulouse, and just try to grind them at their own game.
That was supposed to go in a reply thread, my bad.